I have ranked a couple of your logos which I think are really good candidates. I have eliminated a fair number as well because I didn't feel they were not 'eye-like' enough. I like #18 because for a moment I thought it was Earth visualized from space, which has a nice tie-in with our product which we see being used around the world.
Thanks for your additional submissions, they represent some interesting twists on your original concept, which is still ranked very high. Of the four new submissions, #82 is the most intriguing which seems to combine the eye motif with the organic qualities of a shell. I like it. #81 and #80 are both good, but I don't like either of them better than #18. Take that as a comment on the strength of the latter rather than any negative comment on the former. #79 doesn't resonate with me -- it's meaning doesn't leap out. I'm going to put #82 in the Ranked Logos section so it "lives to fight another day." Thanks for your contributions so far, you do very nice work.
You must have been uploading the new logos just as I was going through the new incoming ones! I like #83 as well as a variation on #18 which I still have in the Ranked section. I don't prefer the new #83 to #18 though, as I really like the idea that when you first look at #18, you think you might be looking at the earth from space -- it's a pleasant image. But the variation you've provided in #83 could potentially have some applications should we decide to proceed with your concept. Thanks again for your hard work, it's much appreciated.
Hi, Alozar, and thank you very much for your additional submissions #89 and #84. I think they're both strong entries, but less suitable than #18, #24 and #82 which I continue to keep in the Ranked category. But these new logos are interesting ideas and thanks again for submitting them.
I have pruned down your ranked entries to the strongest of the three, which is still #18. Frankly, I really like #25 and #82 as well, but one to narrow my choices down to one logo per designer at this stage.
Thanks very much for the additional designs which you submitted today. I have to say I really like them all, and in particular #158. It’s quite abstract, but I still think it ‘reads’ eye when you look at it, which I think is due to the black element in the middle. But at the end of the day, I still think that #18 is the closest to my ideal. It grabbed me when I first looked at it, and it still does. So that’s the one I’m going to use the final rankings. Thanks very much for your additional effort in this phase.