The Beth Smith Shuey TeamLogo Design Contest

Logo Design Contest
Contests / The Beth Smith Shuey Team

The Beth Smith Shuey Team has selected their winning logo design.

For $400 they received 287 designs from 23 different designers from around the world.
1st
#279
5th
#282
6th
#280
7th
#285
8th
#281
9th
#46
10th
#176
New
#268
New
#270
New
#254
New
#269
New
#199
New
#45
New
#231
New
#191
New
#198
New
#163
New
#232
New
#35
New
#283

Withdrawn

New
#287

Withdrawn

New
#286

Withdrawn

New
#284

Withdrawn

New
#253

Withdrawn

New
#164
Prefers others.
#278
Prefers others.
#277
Prefers others.
#276
Prefers others.
#192
Prefers others.
#190
Prefers others.
#184
Prefers others.
#183
Prefers others.
#175
Prefers others.
#174
Prefers others.
#171
Prefers others.
#170
Prefers others.
#167
Prefers others.
#166
Prefers others.
#165
Prefers others.
#162
Prefers others.
#161
Prefers others.
#160
Prefers others.
#123
Prefers others.
#122
Prefers others.
#121
Prefers others.
#111
Prefers others.
#110
Prefers others.
#63
Prefers others.
#62
Prefers others.
#61
Prefers others.
#51
Prefers others.
#47
Prefers others.
#37
Prefers others.
#36
Prefers others.
#33
Prefers others.
#32
Prefers others.
#31
Prefers others.
#26
Prefers others.
#25
Prefers others.
#24

Discussion

 
They are okay, beginning to think the lock is not going to give enough pop. Still thinking about your door (all over the board I know). Didn't realized that was the Elizabeth Arden logo so was a little thrown off. Still need something that says real estate and can stand on its own as my brand...
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi Beth,

I am sorry that I still haven’t managed to make the perfect logo for your business. As you can check from the beginning of the contest I have explored many different concepts (the smile, the initials, the door, the handshake, the key, the bird, the doorknobs).

Personally I don’t think that Elizabeth Arden’s logo and mine look the same, the shape of the door is different and there are no pots with plants so people won’t make any connection between them. If door’s color is the problem then I can change it (check #62, #63 logos).

As a designer I don’t have any more ideas in my sleeve! My goal was to make something original and different from all the other real estate logos, as many of them look identical. If you believe that any of my current logos can represent successfully your business then I’ll be glad to make modifications.

Thank you,
Pink
11 years ago
 
You are so patient and kind, thank you for working with me! One thing I realized was that sometimes I may need black and white photos, can you just show me what the doors would look like in B&W?

The doors really are my favorite design, the problem is more in the long name and tagline than the design, so I'm trying to figure out a way to emphasize the name and still use the doors but not have it so busy....I'm going to get some feedback from others...
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Here you go #253, #254 B&W versions of the door.
I was wondering if you could write your name like that "Beth S. Shuey"... It will make it look shorter
11 years ago
 
Thought I'd responded, sorry! Don't like the Beth S Shuey, considered Smith Shuey, but it's all changing my thoughts...
11 years ago
 
Two things! 1)I have been told more than once that they like your lock better than mine:-! But it looks upside done, maybe have the lock underneath the knob?
11 years ago
 
and 2)what would the lock look like in red? Or black on a red background? Considering all options....

11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
That's funny!
Okay I'll submit some versions in red and rotate it.
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Here you go #268, #269, #270.
I don't think I like much #269, it's very red...
Also black on red background doesn't look nice especially when we have fine lines so I made an option with white on red background.
11 years ago
 
Pink I'm still leaning towards the doors, I had to take a few days off and now need to get serious. Is there any other form of the door that would make it look less Arden? Opened? or what about the door with the skylights and the topiaries on either side? Without the key in the middle....or a mix of that door and the other door....just trying to get it right....

Thanks!
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi Beth :)
I'll search for some different types of door as you want but please keep in mind the following:
* First of all I can't try an open door because another designer did it first and he'll send me to LogoCourt for sure!
* I think that since Arden's door is rectangular we must keep the rounded shape.
Maybe it's the red color that is making the connection, are you open to other colors?
* And last, do you like the pots with the plants, do you want them in your logo?

I'll read your reply and prepare some new variations in the morning.

Thanks!
Pink
11 years ago
 
I think the pots make the logo, they make it look friendly. I hate that you can't take two ideas and make them one, both of you have great starts, is that one of the drawbacks of the tournament?
11 years ago
 
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Hi Beth,
Here are updated entries #276, #277, #278, with double and single doors.
For any modifications please feel free to contact me.
Thank you,
Pink
11 years ago
 
Hi Pink, I agree with you that we should be rectangle and meant to include other images
https://www.dropbox.com/sh/f6ys12pj927qkbk/AABrVEOJN3qhkvpC0NkRHRxla?dl=0
https://www.dropbox.com/sh/f6ys12pj927qkbk/AABrVEOJN3qhkvpC0NkRHRxla?dl=0
Liking the windows idea as well....
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Sorry I'm confused Beth, do you want a circular or a rectangle door?
I'll try and make some similar designs like the pics you sent me.
You mentioned windows, you mean to try a window instead of a door?
11 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Please check new design #279.
11 years ago
 
Ok leaning towards round door with all windows#279, can you show that also with tag line underneath and b) format of 46 with slightly bolder font
10 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Sure Beth, I'll submit new draft asap.
Thanks!
10 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Here you go:
#280: I added tag line
#281: Same as #280 with slightly bolder font
#282: Horizontal version of #280
#283: Horizontal version of #280 with slightly bolder font

Thanks!
10 years ago
 
Great and humor me one more time, the door without the plants, and can you think of any different way to incorporate door only in my name?
10 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Okay...
So, #284 without the plants (it looks so lonely!) and #285 concept, all red letters and the initial letter of your name incorporated in the door.
10 years ago
 
You are right, too lonely without plants. Intrigued by 285, will show that to my team member. Still love door/plants but getting negative feedback from several that it looks hotel like, but I want to get it right. Would there be any other options of plants to give it a slightly different look?
10 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Yes I think #285 is very versatile and it has the "welcome" factor attached with your first name (as friends call you).
Regarding plants, I really don't think that placing different plants will make any difference to the concept (I think they're perfect though).
I mean if you think that it looks like a hotel logo it will look like a hotel logo with different plants!
10 years ago
 
Agreed....would 285 in different wording colors or fonts make a difference? I may need to talk to you about several versions of this door concept, for versatility. After this is finally over, do you still work with clients?
10 years ago
 
Logo Designer
Yes of course I continue working with clients after a contest is completed.
10 years ago
 
1 2 1 2
Login
Home Start on your logo Contests Portfolio Designers Why? Help Contact Us
Forum About Us Pro Accounts
1-800-300-3231