Hi there. We are choosing our winner. To be frank we like your idea but its far away from being out top choice. We really like your style so we wanted to give you another chance to win the competition. For the designs in the next few days I would say try to make it less feminine. Try out some new designs and try some new fonts. We really don't like the font. Altogether try to be creative.
I like the changes you've made and the direction this is taking. Can you continue with the concept of 186? Perhaps experiment by putting arrows around the book image instead of just semicircle lines (if you can do two or three arrows circling the logo, I think that might be effective in communicating the "exchange" part of our website). Also, I like the font in 186 but if you can keep experimenting that would be perfect. Thanks!