Sustain BCLogo Design Contest Logo Design Contest Contests / Sustain BC Sustain BC has selected their winning logo design. For $275 they received 180 designs from 22 different designers from around the world. Find out how LogoTournament works How LogoTournament works Contest Annotation Delete We are sorry, but the time to edit this annotation has expired. Save Cancel Entries by HerDish Return to Contest Return to Contest Comment Activity Order by Ranking Entry Number Comment Activity To leave a comment please click on the logo. 1st 1 Withdrawn 4th Withdrawn 5th 2 Withdrawn 6th Withdrawn 7th Withdrawn 8th Withdrawn 9th 1 Withdrawn 10th Withdrawn New 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. 3 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. 2 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 2 Withdrawn Prefers others. 2 Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. Withdrawn Prefers others. 1 Withdrawn Prefers others. 4 Withdrawn Prefers others. 2 Comment Activity BrentMansfield commented on #177 After getting additional feedback this is our favorite logo. It would be great if we could get this design, as well as the variation in #176 in a couple of different formats: 1. current color scheme 2. all black on white background 3. all white on black background 4. colour on transparent background (so that it could be put on top of a picture) 5. black on a transparent background. This would total 10 different files - 5 variations x 2 different orientations (#177 and #176). 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #180 Withdrawn Great. Thank you very much. 8 years ago HerDish commented on #180 Withdrawn hello sir, im contacting designer for colaborating #179 #180 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #178 Withdrawn Essentially, we'd like to see you mimic this logo but with your font and colours. Thanks! 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #178 Withdrawn Thank you for doing these new designs so quickly! Could you please try one that does the apple portion in the same position as it is in this example: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B__Kio6ZPAnDVWtnOThaOGZHbnM/view?usp=sharing. 8 years ago HerDish commented on #178 Withdrawn turn bitten apple #94 into outline #174 #175 #176 #177 #178 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #171 Withdrawn Hi, We just returned from a Sustain BC planning retreat, which included reviewing the logo options. People really like the font and colors, but some felt the logo was too complex and busy. Would it be possible for you to keep the same font and color, but try with a similar outline of an apple to what is included here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B__Kio6ZPAnDVWtnOThaOGZHbnM/view?usp=sharing. Thanks! 8 years ago HerDish commented on #171 Withdrawn hello sir please let me know if you need to tweak regarding my entries best regards HerDish 8 years ago HerDish commented on #172 Withdrawn tweaking #153 #154 #169 #170 #157 - #171 tweaking #164 #172 #173 sorry sir, im not familiar with salmon, and i have tweak the fish look, what do you think now? please let me know best regards HerDish 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #157 Withdrawn Could you just to one change to this logo: Make the right half of the onion blue, like in many of your other designs. Thanks! 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #164 Withdrawn The fish doesn't quite look like a salmon yet... The head is the wrong shape. It needs to be more oval shaped. Here's another example you could draw from: http://images.freeimages.com/images/premium/previews/8302/8302810-trout-and-salmon-silhouettes.jpg Also, there is no need for an eye. Thanks! 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #154 Withdrawn We like this look- can you keep this exactly as it is, except make the line, where it meets the fork, as skinny as in #166? 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #153 Withdrawn We like this look- can you keep this exactly as it is, except make the line, where it meets the fork, as skinny as in #164? 8 years ago HerDish commented on #168 Withdrawn another tweak #159 #160 #161 #162 #163 #164 #165 #166 #167 #168 8 years ago HerDish commented on #150 Withdrawn hello sir here are revision as per request, tweaking #135 #150 #151 #152 tweaking #141 #153 #154 #155 tweaking #140 #156 #157 #158 please let me know what do you think about the new fish look, best regards HerDish 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #140 Withdrawn It's nice to see some different varieties of where the fork its. Can we see one more version of this: Move the fork to the upper left (instead of upper right), and then add the blue to the onion (the right portion like #148) 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #141 Withdrawn We really like the circle starting skinny and widening out. However, we think it may look better if the line where thinner where it met the fork. Can you make this shift and then we'd like to see two other versions: 1) Same design but adding blue to the onion (the right portion like #148) 2) Green circle instead of blue. AND, add the blue to the onion (the right portion like #148) 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #135 Withdrawn We really like the onion as designed. For this design, we'd like to see a different type of fish. Specifically, we are hoping you can do something with the fish similar to this rotated to look good in your design (using the fish only, not the fly): http://media.istockphoto.com/vectors/trout-silhouette-vector-id165630557?k=6&m=165630557&s=170667a&w=0&h=ver-JZig7NarpieAB9i70PSpzkOz2itaRJtLAOP-meM= This is a silhouette of a salmon. 8 years ago HerDish commented on #144 Withdrawn another simple #144 #145 #146 #147 #148 8 years ago HerDish commented on #143 Withdrawn simplify #141 #142 #143 8 years ago HerDish commented on #136 Withdrawn onion in the middle of circle #132 #133 #134 #135 #136 on entry #136 split onion with two colors, on of blue part of onion is some kind like water, so it half water, and half onion, and fish wrapped around on the upper right, make it look like, fish swim around the circle, somehow like that, please let me know what can i do for the onion, best regards HerDish 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #116 Withdrawn Thanks for the new designs. We would like to see three variations. In all of these designs, can you give the onion more shading and give it roots- you can take inspiration from the logo here: http://news.perlfoundation.org/ 1- Keep the logo the same, but update the onion taking inspiration from http://news.perlfoundation.org/ 2- Do the updates in 1 but then also remove the leaf in the upper right corner of the circle to make the logo less busy. 3- We just want to see the updated onion within the circle (no apple at all), and we want you to replace the leaf on the upper-right of the circle with a fish. 8 years ago HerDish commented on #123 Withdrawn beet #121 #122 #123 8 years ago HerDish commented on #120 Withdrawn include onion in the middle in negative space, and change leaf to fish complete with eye, #116 #117 #118 #119 #120 best regards HerDish 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #93 Withdrawn Prefer the colour palate on the other designs. See the other comment about exploring other foods, such as an onion, radish or beet in the centre, and a fish instead of a leaf. 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #95 Withdrawn Would it be possible to explore a tweak to this general design. We got some feedback from a member of the Steering Committee that they would like to something other than an apple, with idea of making the leaf a fish and have an onion, say, in the middle. Would that be possible? 8 years ago HerDish commented on #107 Withdrawn monochrome and one color black white preview #105 #106 #107 please let me know best regards HerDish 8 years ago HerDish commented on #90 Withdrawn another slim fork #90 #91 another fruit, apple/cherry #92 #93 #94 #95 #96 preview single icon #97 #98 best regards HerDish 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #58 Withdrawn This blue is nice. The pineapple looked good, but there are no pineapples grown in BC (British Columbia, Canada), so we can't use that unfortunately. Maybe one of the following: cherries, apple (a more stylized version than last time), peach, plum, pears, grapes, radishes, beets, cherries. Take your pick or try a few. Also, I'd like to see the fork less fat. Perhaps you can make it a three tined fork instead of having four tines? 8 years ago HerDish commented on #67 Withdrawn pineapple #67 #68 #69 #70 #71 #72 best regards HerDish 8 years ago HerDish commented on #58 Withdrawn editing #40 changing dark green into blue #58 #59 #60 will try another fruit in the middle sir, best regards HerDish 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #40 Withdrawn I definitely like this more without a line. I think I would prefer blues over the dark green. 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #42 Withdrawn I like the idea, but the apple is too simple. Perhaps other vegetables that are more stylized. Would prefer a blue rather than the dark green. 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #45 Withdrawn Nice idea, but it feels a little too busy. 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #46 Withdrawn Heart is a little too cheesy 8 years ago HerDish commented on #46 Withdrawn another revision #38 #39 - pure without line #40 - another color green #41 - bitten apple #42 #43 #44 - apple #45 - carrot #46 heart please let me know sir.. i will try another rotation of fork best regards Herdish 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #7 Withdrawn Things grown in BC that you can play with: apples, peaches, plums, pears, grapes, radishes, beets, cherries. Fishing is also big in BC, but shouldn't dominate a logo (salmon, crab, prawns). Other food symbols welcome: knife, fork, spoon. 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #7 Withdrawn It would be interesting to see something other than a leaf in the middle of the emblem as well. 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #7 Withdrawn Mixing elements in the logo in this way are nice (e.g. leaves and a fork- could be other ideas but like that it's not just one or the other, but mixed in an interesting way). Would be neat to see some other elements mixed together for diversity. Like that the icon can be placed above or to the side, making the logo more square or rectangular as we need. 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #8 Withdrawn Leaves on their own are too generic for a logo 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #6 Withdrawn See comments on other logo. Like both placements of logo- versatile. 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #7 Withdrawn Like the logo- it has nice elements. The fork kind of looks like an electrical plug-in so could be subtly modified. Line above Sustain isn't needed. Colours are a bit muted. 8 years ago BrentMansfield commented on #6 Withdrawn We like this, but are not so sure about the line. 8 years ago