This is getting tough. I'm trying to comment on the top 2-3 designs in case you want to see what we're thinking at this point. I consulted a couple people on #73 and this is what we came up with:
The outline around the logo/graphic could be a tiny bit thicker. (Is this the outline you thought looked "oldish"? I'd be curious to hear why-- you might change my mind on it.)
The relative sizes of the typed out logo and the graphic could be closer. Right now the graphic kind of over powers the text in size. I think if the text got too big, though, the opposite would happen and the graphic would look dinky in comparison.
And a couple folks mentioned that the white SW letters looked kind of <quote> "Star Wars-ish." Here, I don't know what to suggest. It could be as simple as just trying a different 'S'.
Other than that, there are 1-2 very minor changes. The really strong part everyone agreed on was the reflective/marble effect on the graphic. One person thought it might be interesting to see the same effect but a different color than red, just to see what it'd look like.
Thanks very much.