Regarding #21: I like the "swoosh" on the graphic. I'm not crazy about the little circles on top of the sling shot though. Can you take those off? I like the more italicized font, but could you use something a little more rounded? Also, please note that it is "Designs" and not "Design". I would like to see some "action lines" around the font too, to give the feeling that the words are moving quickly to the right.
Regarding #24: I prefer more of a round font. When I said "action lines", I meant some lines separate from the actual font... to make it look like the words are moving. It's hard to explain lol... just draw some lines underneath the words. Also, can you please take off the circles on the top of the sling shot? I would rather they be pointed. I also like the circle filled in with color, like the ones you have been doing so far. Thanks, you're doing a great job!
Regarding #28: I love the change! Can you make the line underneath the words straight? I am trying to make it look like the words are moving, so the line would be sort of like the wind. You might need to add more than one line for that effect. Also, if you could make the font a little smaller and more to the left. Thanks!!
Hi, thank you for being so responsive. I feel like we are really making progress, and that you understand what I am trying to achieve. :-)
Regarding #31: can you make the line under the words thinner? Then you could add another thin line under that one, only not as long as the first one. Again, I am just trying to achieve the sense that the words are moving, with a trail of "wind" around them lol.
Regarding #33: Can you make the top line just a little thinner? Also, I would like some color or some kind of other effects on the font, like making it shiny or shadowed in certain areas. Does that make sense?
I liked both of them a lot. I couldn't tell the difference between #35 and #36 though, so I just chose #36. Could you do one where the orange circles are coming out of the sling shot in more of a straight line, instead of in an arc? Maybe just reduce the arc size a little bit. I want to give the impression of speed an accuracy.
On #49, can you make just a little bit more of an arc? Sorry, I'm not trying to be difficult. It can be a challenge to describe this just over messages. But you are doing a great job!
Can you put together a sling shot graphic that is a combination of #36 and #11? I am wondering how #36 would look without all of the balls coming out of it, and instead just use one ball like you have in #11. I think #11 is a little too "relaxed" though, and I would like to see more action, like the sling shot is getting ready to strike. Does that make sense? Thanks!
Much better, thank you! I was wondering if you could change the font on the words? I am looking at #72, and I like that font much better. Also observe how the "action lines" around the words. If you could do something like that it would be awesome. And can you also do one with a light green ball instead of an orange one? I think we are getting very close. Thanks!
Oh wow, I love #80. If you look at #72, I like the actual font they are using, especially the letter "g". I know you are not supposed to copy the work of other designers, but could you find a font similar to that? I really appreciate how responsive you have been and if you win I will definitely use you for more graphics that I need to have done.
ok.thanks maybe I'll draw a straight line in the letter 'g' and 't' only, because the other entries have been using it first, I hope you understand my. thanks regards
Well, in English there are two ways to show the letter "g". Here is what I mean: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:LowercaseG.svg. I like the "double-story" g better than the "single-story." Can you find a cool font that uses that kind of g?
Wow, #82 is awesome. Thank you! Just one little thing... on the "t" , can you make it more like #81, where the line underneath ends with the "t"? On #82, you have the line extending past the "t" and I think it looks better if it ends when the "t" ends. Otherwise, this is perfect. :-)
I like how you made the sling shot bigger on #113. However, it is almost too big. Can you make it just a little bit smaller, but not as small as #83. Thanks...
Nothing is wrong with your design, I really like it. You are competing with #111 and #116 right now. What I like about theirs is that they give a feeling of "fast action", like they are about to strike at something. That is one of the feelings I really want in the logo. I really like your style, and I have lots of other graphics design that I will need done after this (for an iPhone app) and I think you would be excellent for that. If you don't win this contest, I would still like the opportunity to have you work on those other things. Do you have a website?
#148 is really good. It adds the feeling of action that I was talking about. Just because you are in 2nd place doesn't mean I have made up my mind yet. This is going to be a very difficult decision!
ok thanks, I really understand you, that to choose one of the best of the many design entry is a very difficult thing, when I was in your position I also find it difficult to select the winner, thanks, regards