I don't want to be too radical here but, I like the design but a few of my workforce don't! I pay the bills so it's stay at No2 for now - I'd like it at No1.
Concerns: the 'O' in shore is disliked by a few of those I've asked for opinions and I'd like to see more contrast in the text to bring out the wave a lot more.
Likes: The Angler is spot on, the aspect ratio is spot on, the colours are spot on. It will work in both web and T-Shirt formats [less for T shirts which is the sticking part, maybe I need to take that forward myself]