#131 #132 The S looks a bit too much like graffiti. I'm also not sure if the 3D effect will translate well to silhouette. The font is also a bit too light and not very smooth...
I had to have a closer look at #119 to realise I actually liked it - the middle white layer wasn't obvious at first. Maybe it would be nice if the middle layer was easier to see? The best thing about #119 though is that the graphic and word work together as a whole - the shape of the whole logo is cool.
#142 #143 #144 I can see these working better in print than #131, but I still don't like the graffiti-style S.
#148 #149 #150 #151 Thank you for reading the updated brief! Playing on the G's is cool, however as "sfoggle" isn't a word most people will read it as "sfogdle" since the rotated G looks like a D - and the logo reads as "GD" especially in #150 and #151.
I really like the colours in #149 though! And the graphic is really cool if only it didn't read as GD... maybe you could rotate the second G in the lettering back to normal, and then move the blue second G down a bit so the 2 G's form an S?
#181 I like this one the most, but can the grey middle curve be shinier? And the rest of the logo have a nicer shading effect like Max's #106?
#167 This one is nice, but the curve is the wrong way so it's not an S anymore... but more balanced than #182.
#178 Blue is too dark #175 #176 Small curve is rotated funny and looks unbalanced #169 #170 Don't like the purple here #168 Don't like the lighter blue here
I think #149 has a lot of potential... would be nice to see what you can do with it!