We definitely want the "o" to be a focal point (even though its off center) but I really feel like the ribbon idea is pretty well saturated in the world of "issue awareness" graphic design and is probably near the end of its trendiness. We are looking for something more timeless. Your entry #1 is nice with the weight of the smaller type balancing the "O", but I prefer the "scholarliness" of the small caps you used in #3 and #4. I also like the double line being interrupted by the "O", especially in #4 where the line appears to be in the background, yet is visually continued through the top of the heart. This one seems to have a lot of depth to it, which I like, but the colors are not at all what we are looking for. Even though colorectal cancer affects men and women, its more generally associated with males, therefore, we are looking for more masculine coloring. Cadet blue, black and a dull light orange was the general consensus from the Drs.
I just looked at your portfolio on your profile - Really nice work!! The ones I particularly liked - thinking the concept might work for our logo - were WCS Logistics with the apple, Pepe Rendon and The Solutions Group.
I'm sorry, I didn't mean to confuse you. The coloring on #9 is really good, but both #9 and #10 are a little crazy with the curls - too feminine. Could you look at your logos for WCS Logistics, Pepe Rendon and The Solutions Group again and incorporate the clarity you used with those? Read my first comments again, too, please.
(side note: instead of saying "thanks for feedbacking", say "Thank you for your feedback")
Good Morning, Jessica! Your entry #19 is REALLY good - I'd like to see just two changes ~ I like the horizontal lines above and below SCOLAR, but could you make them blue or black? And also, the image inside the "O" is too geometric. I'd like you to, as best as you can, replicate the interior of our example logo.