A little too whimsical I think. Perhaps a little on the scary / edgy side please. This is a winery, and a brewery, so I don't want to show a wine bottle / wine glass and leave the beer impression out. A little concerned on copyright issues on stealing the phantom of the opera mask? Don't know a lot on that topic though.
Still like 52 best. This might be better with some color contrast though. Red eyes? I'd really like something more human like at the end of the day though.