#11 We like this little Smurf/Blob, but please describe the thought around this figure. This font is very close to what we thought of in the beginning.
Would it be possible to see this some more colorful scheme? Also, the little Blob could have some expressions?
#11 This is still our favorite, very simple and easy going. But it still lacks expression... :-) #17 and #16 was to "childish"... But it is still not that far from what we could go with. Try keeping the "Simplicity"!
We would like to make a pretty specific suggestion regarding #11 and #25. Remove the "teeth", and extend the body all the way down to the logo baseline, then make a smile out of a line on the body, making it a bit more subtle. Could we see such a change for both colors?
It's very hard to explain, but #11 is still the best one here due to it's "Simplicity" and that it's a bit odd. #51 has some nice shadow element on the icon.
We changed #11 to #62 because it was a bit larger and easy to reference to the other logos.
We really do not know what to do, #62 has some nice reflecting which might work. It's also extended to the baseline as we spoke of before. What would happen if you put a smaller mouth inside the "blob"? Not extending to both sides like #50 and #51...
Also, maybe play with the eye's a bit, trying to get another expression on the face...
We are convinced that this icon works with expressions. Take the pupils of #80 and put into #79. Then we have a great icon.
Now to the font, please experiment with some different types, too many of the suggestions are of the same type... We do want to go a bit more web 2.0... Though; Remember "Simplicity first"