i love the thought behind the horseshoe and fish idea in entry #39. don't like the "star wars" text though. really on the right track. The current font in our logo is Arial Black so I like the boldness but maybe you can come up with something different.
entry #44 is good as well. I would change the "Y" to not be the fish tail and fit with the rest of the "luck" so we don't get mistaken for "Luck Strike"
#106- Best of the horseshoe designs, much easier to read than others. makes use of traditional lucky strike emblem. very well suited for packaging, stickers and metal stamping. this is our lop choice of all your designs.
#106- I really like the look of it but Someone pointed out that it might be read "CLUCKY STRIKE" can you do a version of #106 with thin outline around the fish and no horseshoe.
Thank you for your designs. we selected your logo because it has elements of a stand-alone iconic fishing logo. we were wanting our logo to be a sticker that fisherman put on their boat or truck. if you have time to please view the new attached file I have created for just the top 5 designers. the file is named "iconic fishing logo" we created the fish today in our office to give you another idea. please view it and submit any elements that you like.