Entry #11 - I really like this design but not a fan of the aqua color. I might like an orange and light gray combo or a darker blue (not dark blue) and green combo. Thank you, this is excellent.
Entry #9 - My partner likes this one best...though I get the final say and I prefer #11. I would have a similar comment on the colors. Not a big fan but like the direction you are going here.
Entry #33 - Wow, I love that. Well done! Is it possible to make a Trulia type map marker that spirals at the bottom? I like this pin and may like it better than the twisted map marker but then again, I may be able to use a twisted map marker in the logo as well as in the map search itself. Very cool, thank you!
#41 - That's funny, I was just about to say that I prefer it the other way around color wise. I love what you did with the "i" in the twist. I envisioned the map marker being twisted and not having the silver pin coming out of it to twist. Is it possible to taper the map marker into a gradual twist like you have the metal part of the pin? Hope that makes sense. Maybe you can make the top of the marker to be more round to avoid looking like the trulia marker. Thank you!
Wow, I guess I get what I ask for. :) I envisioned it looking a little cooler. Maybe being a little thicker with less twists and the twists not being so wide would help. I still like your first draft with the pin #33 the best though I like the way you did the fonts in #52 with the dot on the i. I thought it would be cool to have a cool map marker that I could use in the logo that could also be used in the map search as the map markers. Thank you for your hard work. I like #16, #19 and #33 better than anything else out there. There are a few things ranked higher because my partner wants her say in the matter but you are by far the best designer I have seen so far. Thank you!
Can we try a combination of two of your designs. I LOVE the magnifying glass and house in #16 and fonts in #52. Can you combine those two elements? Plus make the mag the same height as the stacked words. Your designs are so much cleaner than most I've seen. Can I see them in a blue/gray combo and a blue/green combo? Thank you!
Thanks, I really like that change. My partner loves how another designer implemented the map marker and magnifying glass into the name so we are battling over that internally. :)
I'm afraid I can't do that. Fresh Designs was first and it's his/her idea, so anything that is similar to his concept would be considered as copy. Anyway, there's still plenty of room for modifications of existing design and creating new one.
I'm glad you're back. You have the cleanest designs I've seen. I have to be honest, I like the original direction you were taking the design more. The e is larger than the rest of the word (for obvious reasons) but it just doesn't quite fit together for me. I do like that you made it into a magnifying glass with a house though. I can see that you were trying to implement the pin into the t as well but it doesn't look like a pin or a t to me. I'm sorry for the negative feedback because I would like to see you take this to the next level. Thank you!
I understand how you feel. I only had two designs ranked above your designs. All of your designs held the 3-9 positions. The two that were ranked above you were nothing like your designs. There were several of your designs that I left unranked because they were the same design with just a different color so I didn't think I should have an exact same design hold 5 spots just because it was different color combinations. Maybe that's how it should be, I don't know because I've never done this before. What I do know is that I liked two of your designs more than any of the other designs. My team all voted for #79 so I had it in first place. One more design came in today that my partner loved and she placed it as number one. Ultimately it is my decision though. Can you place your designs back up on the last day so that I can still choose from them at the last moment? That way no one can copy you but you still have the ability to win. Is that a fair compromise?
One more thing to say, I am not the one that wronged you and I am sorry others have tried to copy your work. Please do not hold it against me for other people's unprofessional behavior. I love your work and would love the option to choose from your designs when this contest ends in 4 days. I hope you will reconsider but if you do not, please know that I do believe you have the cleanest designs I have seen so far and wish you the best.
I can't see any problems with you or your behaviour, no way. Your feedback helps us improving designs and pushes us to do more quality works and I want to thank you for this. I'm really glad you like my work and I will think of re-submitting them on the last day, since this is the primary purpose of this site - chance to choose best logo from all the submissions :)
Thank you Paull, I hope you do resubmit. It would mean a lot to me to have that option. Maybe you will think of something new to post on the last day that will blow my whole team away. On the last day, my team will come in and we will all look over every design and make a decision as a team. ... You know, that may not be a bad design idea! Wait until the last two days to start submitting your ideas, that way there is a reduced chance that someone can copy you. The risk is that someone else may think of your great idea before you have a chance of submitting it and then it would look like you are copying them.