So far you're tied for first - I really like the idea. I like the Guardian you have in gray, but lets take off the INC. And lets see how it'd look with a lighter blue dot on the i. I continue to welcome your creativity!
I like what I'm seeing - lets make the font like Grafixsphere, entry # 46 and put the logo on the left side with Guardian Insurance Agency Inc on the right. Let's also see how it'd look to make the Insurance blue along with the dot. You're obviously good at what you do and are still in the top 3. Thank you!
#317 - My apologies for the late entry, but it occurred to me that a guard tower of a castle would best represent what your company stands for. Strength, protection, foresight, superiority. I'd love to develop the idea further if you agree.