After receiving much feedback from our board, your logo is very popular! We like the colour selection of #29 the best, but there are two concerns: 1. The 'spike' is not actually a proper spike. 2. The society name is not balanced.
I am wondering if you could do one last submission where the train is perhaps smaller, with no smoke and the words 'Golden Spike Days' around the outside with no smoke interrupting the wording. Also, if you could find a refine the spike to look more like those presented in the other logos. It must actually look like a railroad spike and this one is a bit too conceptual on that part.
One other potential addition: perhaps a maple leaf somewhere (maybe in the centre circle of the train)? This is less important than the other changes, but it is something that a number of our board members were interested in including.