Enteries #1,2, & 3 turned us off because of the halo and wings, which references religion, chiefly Christianity. We did like your other designs, however :)
None of the fonts really seem to fit. Also, green and brown doesn't seem right. It looks like Girl Scouts. Can you try it without brown? Maybe green and purple? Also entry #12 with the red being a different color. Red is a little more harsh than we wanted.
Something that looks more handwritten might be nice for the handcrafted feel. Sorry we don't have anything specific in mind, we're kind of just feeling it out to see what hits us :)
Would there be any way at all to try and incorporate the rainbow aspect of #12, #24, #25, with the heart shape of the others? I love the shape, and I love the rainbow idea because it speaks to how we want to appeal to women of all ethnicities.