Entry 19 is much more the direction that I like. I like the incorporation of the smaller elements. I like the red in the font a lot more than I expected. I prefer white backgrounds for the logo.
Also the thing with entry 3 and 11 is that we prefer darker fonts. Also those are a bit 'loopy' and we need something that is a little less feminine while still retaining a certain playfulness.
Number 19 is more the direction we want to go I think but I just don't really like the font. It also needs to incorporate some original elements into it.
Also number 4 is growing on me quite a bit but not a fan of the off-white/yellow background. The feather, arrow, foot thing is cool but maybe with something else for the feather and arrow. A bit too hipster for me.
here's a little more info that we just posted, might give you a little more clarity;
our locale is down a little ally way that is quiet and tucked away. A few seats are out the fron but its small, intimate and homely inside with a lively feel. its also situated in the older historic part of the town
hope thats not too contradictory, but im just trying to imagine the fit with the cafe/bar offering and its location
your designs are a little different and we're liking that, would be great to see some more :)