Entry 6: We like the x. It brings in the community part of this club/list, but the x kind of looks like a golf ball on a tee. Font looks a little too modern to go with the brand logo on the website.
Entry 4: we like the idea of wine in the top of the x, but this looks like a bubbling cauldron. We like it because it could be any wine or spirit and not just wine. The club may eventually expand into liquors, so this wouldn't limit us.
Entry 8: Like the orange. Don't like the o and the emblem looks too much like a country.
We really want to like this concept, but the x is still bothering us. Great colors and and I do like the three dots at the end. It is almost like etc... and suggests there is much, much more to explore.
Thank you very much about the feedback! I will be back at home in a few hours when I'll upload all the designs, which would include the requests you made.
Removed the liquid from the "X" and changed the concept with it.
In #44 - made it as a person / butterfly. The person symbol is clear and the butterfly is for exploring, developing, transforming...
In #45 - changed the "X" in something that shows the development, the exploring - an arrow directed right in orange and the other "ends/options" form the "x" in different colors all mirrored with the "expect more" dots .
Thank you, Angelina, for your creative designs. We decided to go with another logo that went more with the overall brand. We really appreciate your efforts.