Erie County Historical SocietyLogo Design Contest Logo Design Contest Contests / Erie County Historical Society Erie County Historical Society has selected their winning logo design. For $275 they received 88 designs from 11 different designers from around the world. Find out how LogoTournament works How LogoTournament works Contest Annotation Delete We are sorry, but the time to edit this annotation has expired. Save Cancel Entries by Dzains Return to Contest Return to Contest Comment Activity Order by Ranking Entry Number Comment Activity To leave a comment please click on the logo. Withdrawn 3rd 12 Withdrawn New 3 Withdrawn New Withdrawn New Withdrawn New Withdrawn New Withdrawn Prefers others. Comment Activity Dzains commented on #31 Withdrawn Hello, unfotunatelly the "ship" concept is protected. Anything else you might want me to incorporate, please ask. Thank you for your patience Elena 8 years ago wdd commented on #31 Withdrawn ok, have a good night. I also want to mention that this latest revision was for a "steamer" - a type of ship that sailed on the lakes. I understand that you couldn't do the traditional sailing ship or lighthouse. This request for a steamer is something different. Thanks again for your time. 8 years ago Dzains commented on #31 Withdrawn Please give me some time to check on that and I will let you know if I can submit. It's midnight here so I will let you know in the morning. Thank you! 8 years ago wdd commented on #31 Withdrawn This idea did not come from a designer. And you are correct it was not mentioned in the original brief. Our client came up with the idea after this contest has started. I certainly don't want you to get in any trouble! 8 years ago Dzains commented on #31 Withdrawn So this idea was your clients and you just passed it to a designer? Because nothing like that was mentioned in the brief. Sorry to be thorough but if this idea came from another designer that could lead me into trouble 8 years ago wdd commented on #31 Withdrawn This was actually a request from our client. No designer has presented anything like this to this point. 8 years ago Dzains commented on #31 Withdrawn May I ask if the ship and lighthouse was your ideas that you told another designer on a private message or these ideas were brought to light by another designer? 8 years ago wdd commented on #31 Withdrawn Based on your previous comments you may not be able to do this, but I t thought I'd ask, because we still like this design very much. Is there any way you can pull the "bridge element" out and replace it with a "stylized steamer ship"? Here are some links for reference in no particular order: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e7/Steamer_A_Wherle,_Jr._(14166647113).jpg http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-pJf2BK-qtco/T5hjB28GXrI/AAAAAAAACrE/5J4KT89zn2U/s1600/tran502copy.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/54/Steamer_R._B._Hayes_(14143265161).jpg https://www.cardcow.com/images/set393/card00388_fr.jpg http://www.boatnerd.com/news/newsthumbs/images-07-1/10-Put-In-Bay-djw.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/94/SS_City_of_Detroit_III.jpg 8 years ago Dzains commented on #31 Withdrawn I understand what you are saying but we have very very strict rules on other designers ideas - even if executed differently. I wish I could. 8 years ago wdd commented on #31 Withdrawn Based on your experience with logo tournament, I'm sure you know the rules very well. But neither, this ship or lighthouse have been submitted by anyone else to the point. There have been sailboats and other lighthouses but these are specific. If you still can't submit, I understand but I wanted to clarify. Thanks again for your submissions. 8 years ago Dzains commented on #31 Withdrawn Unfortunately, the shop and lighthouse have been alread used by other designers and I am not allowed to use their ideas. 8 years ago wdd commented on #31 Withdrawn We like this look. Can you show me something similar using one or both of the elements? (remove the bridge element) maybe a historic ship http://www.thetravelingpraters.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/USS-Niagara-Tall-Ships.jpg and maybe this lighthouse in the background. Huron Lighthouse http://www.remarkableohio.org/galleries/Erie_County/14-22_Hurons_Maritime_History/397_5607.jpg 8 years ago Dzains commented on #23 Withdrawn of course! I just submitted some revisions. If you need to see any othe modifications, please let me know. Thank you Elena K. 8 years ago wdd commented on #23 Withdrawn could you make "Historical Society" a little larger? 8 years ago Dzains commented on #23 Withdrawn Hello and thank you for the rank! Is there any specific modifications you would like to see in the design? Thank you Elena K. 8 years ago