jesicastudio's, I assume that you withdrew your entries because you are making modifications to them? I like your concept the best. Please resubmit when you are ready.
ive make the "rebuild" of logo. but other contestant said that i've copied his/her concept, so i decide to withdraw it. cause i just want to do fair tournament here.. but i will try again ASAP.
#15, I like can you submit an additional rendering without the mayan like design at the top of the coin. Maybe with "Empire" across the top and "Coin" across the bottom.
Jessica, will you be resubmitting the version of your design with the pyramid in the middle? I wanted to make some suggestions on that rendering as well.
#16, this is looking great. I'd like to see it with a white background. Your #17 looks great, but can't see any real difference between 16 & 17 except the background. Is it just a little bit smaller with a white background?
im so sorry about the pyramid, other contestant dont said that it protected by him.. so i cant use that element.. but ill try to figure it better.. just wait.. i will help you till you satisfied..
#24, Jess...this is looking great! I like that the pyramid is in 3D and that it appears to be gold bars stacked on each other. Just great! I like that the circle above it with the EC looks like a sun above it, I just think it's too prominent. Can you make that circle a little bit smaller in size so as to allow the pyramid to be more prominent? Leave that design up, just configure a rendering with a smaller circle, and adjust the pyramid size a tiny bit larger (but not much). Great work.
thanks maurice, i will take take changes ASAP. im still at out of home. maybe two or three hours again, i will rebuild it again, just be patient . i will ready in all time to give feedback for you.
#34, I like this new rendering with the gold bars. Let's try a new rendering of this version with the pyramid having a frosted look. View this site for an example: http://www.goldline.com/coins-goldamericaneagle-proof. In the proof coins, the field of the coin has a mirror like finish while the actual design in the coin is frosted. I'd like for the yellow/gold color to be toned down a bit to see what that looks like. Remove the circle with the EC in this version, just have the pyramid in the middle. I was also thinking of something along the edge in between the company name, like small embossed stars. Also refer to the link above for an idea.
#33, I'd like to see the same thing. Another rendering (leave the originals up) with the color change, removal of the circle with EC, frosted pyramid, and something along the borders of the coin.
#35, I think the black/purple background behind the pyramid itself helps distinguish it more. I like the direction you're going in. The "Empire Coin" is a little difficult to see, see what you can do to make it stand out a little more.
Jess, I still like #33 and #34 the best. In #42 it's almost easy to lose sight of what the stacked bars are because they are too close up. Let's remove the circle with the EC in #33 & 34 and see what that looks like.