Hey there - I've submitted the following according to your last two messages:
#99 and #100 - Added gold and midnight blue elements respectively.
#101 - Demonstrates a thinner treatment to the bottom border.
#102 - Adjusted the name so it doesn't appear to be sinking and introduced another border treatment.
I really appreciate your dilemma in regards to the border treatment. What I suggest you do is look at it as two different designs. If you select the brand design you are most happy with, then you can experiment with a border treatment that will most *enhance* the design and the packaging as a whole. It might take printing out different treatments and actually applying them to your bottle. As such, I think the design process related to this project has to continue after this contest ends. I really don't think there is any way for you to know what the treatment will look like with just the images displayed here. Like I said earlier, I would be happy to work with you to develop your brand.
Would I would advice you is to look at the product. It is eco-minded as well as being pure and transparent. The packaging is going to have to follow suit. My early design, the one you like best, took all this into consideration. I wanted to communicate "purity" so that the only thing "moving" were a few air bubbles. What's purer than that? Against this, the orange treatment for the name broadcasts style, modernity and sophistication. If you take this into consideration, then the border treatment becomes secondary and can be chosen through a process of trial and error. All this - by the way - is why I'm irritated with my colleagues here who have followed suit and used the same color treatment and other elements. One thing is to have a strong theory that's thought out behind the design, another thing altogether is to apply a treatment simply because it is highly ranked.
Just ask yourself what you want to communicate. What are you communicating with a clear background as opposed to a dark background? What are you communicating with one style of movement, like a few air bubbles, against another more agressive movement? And what is the source of the movement? -- etc, etc.
Ok - I think I've written a novel here, or a short-story anyway. I hope it helps your process if even in a small way. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you!
-Ignacio