Thank you for participating and submitting so many designs. We like the concept of #32. It shows some depth and we like that the red figure is clearly in the front of the line.
We aren't a fan of the bevel, or glossy approach in your designs though. Also, we feel like the figures are a bit too whimsical. We usually don't add any element of 3D to our logos and prefer for them to be more flat (see the file in our brief). We feel that your current figure looks more like a ghost.
Could we see a new logo that shows the line that fades into the background of the logo with a strong red figure in the forefront. Maybe a turnstile just behind that figure.
Use the styles of the top ranked current logos to see more of the look & feel we want for the figures and turnstile.
from a team member: #56 and #64 - Two things - I wish these logo designs could be completely inside the circle. They go external to the circle while all the rest of our logos are within. And the blue I would make a darker royal/navy like the color combo we have now (and like many of the other designs).
Other feedback - There's something about the y-shaped guy w/ his arms up that I don't like. Jillian and Sadie said they didnt like that either, that it looked like an Olympic dismount or something. What if it was just a man standing there up front by himself, just like the other figures. No arms, but he stands out and is clearly at the front rather than in line.
I prefer the one arm like #56 rather than two arms.