We are a smaller boat company and portals are for larger boat companies. That doesn't really represent us well. I like the contemporary one - the colors are great! My concern is if people see only a sailboat, they tend to classify us.
Your design is simple and effective at getting attention. It grabbed me immediately when I saw it. I sent it to my team this morning and it seems to be a favorite for those that have responded so far. Prior to us buying the name, it was a microwave company. We are a boating services company (sales, marketing, admin and support with online reservations. Could the wave look more like an ocean wave? something that more clearly says water. Otherwise, I need a tag line or picture.