I got another email from Ivan F stating that is was OK for you to submit your logo designs. Please resubmit them. I will be putting together a package for my partners and I to vote on.
I know 70 artist is your problem. I did some research on great logos. 99% of the top logos use four colors or less. If you look at 70, how many colors would guess he used? I am going to say dozens because of all of the shading, etc. He needs to re-work his design before we vote on it. If it doesn't look right, guess who wins?
Do you understand that I am putting the 3 sets of logos together so that I can easily reference them when reviewing with the other artist? He has to make another update and then the two sets will be voted on. Assuming there is something to vote on.
Listen. I am your partner in this all the way. I have emails to support what I told you and will fight on your behalf. which I don't expect to even have to do. If I have to, I will pick another logo just so that you stay out of harms way. All you have to do is let me know if you are getting any grief and I will work out a solution so that you are not harmed (you just tell me what you need me to do to assist).
My comments also stated that your 106 was a close second, possibly first. That's because of the voting. I have 3 other partners and we all get to vote.
I have to go back to my partners and let them see the variants of 106 and 70. so that we can make our final vote. I have only seen logo 106 in blue and green. I am pulling for 106 now and my partners have all been leaning towards 66/106. So most likely you will win.
Go to Creative Sports contest attachments and review my screenprint from Ivan F. I will be deleting shortly. Just want you to see that you have received approval. But, I am going to delete to avoid controversy. If you still want to wait until later that's fine too.
I had email conversations with both Tyler Quinn and Ivan F regarding this issue and Ivan F determined that your 106 logo was not infringing. Please ask him yourself if you need assurance.
His "S" is multi-dimensional (shading, etc.) and technically your "S" in logo 106 does not break left and right to the same degree as his. I don't understand how the two "S"'s are that close in design.
Also, if you "re-enter" logo 106 to this competition, you can state that I personally directed you to do it. I need this logo to speak with the Mgmt of Logo Tournament so that they can determine if their is any infringement on the other artists design.
Don't worry I am fully prepared to address this with the Mgmt of Logo Tournament. I am not going to tolerate another artist using broad and manipulative tactics to try and secure the "win" for their logo, when in fact there is no infringement on the design.
Sorry for the confusion. But the original blue and green logo that I added the comments to is the potential winning logo. You added the full S and the other logo had the subtle S which is what I liked. My request was to just use that blue/green logo and make a few color variations of it. Could do 3 to 4 versions of that logo a S well as a Black and White version - meaning the entire logo is black.
Comment Activity
Once received I will approve and you can get paid.
Thank you!
Scott
Thanks for finalized the contest, i just uploaded the final files,
please approves under "my contest" button, so they can release the prize.
Thanks a lot.
csd
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Thanks a lot
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Thank you!
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Thank you!
Withdrawn
Thank you!
Withdrawn