#4 - I like the color swatch, the artwork is a little too cliparty, not enough chalkboard, font a little too elegant
#3 - same as #4 - swirls a little distracting
#2 - same as #4, not loving the font - something bolder
#1 - same as #4 - too many colors though...
I like the idea of having the wine and cheese there in the logo, didn't think about that -see what we can do to make it more like hand drawn like chalk art...