I like 23 the most at the moment because:
- Clear and simple ClubIT wording
- The Word Magic is masculine/strong enough where as some of the other entries the word magic looks a little comedical/funny and not serious enough(such as 21,15,12).
The only thing I don't like about 23 is that it lacks the creativity in the word magic like the others (for example the use of stars, or the other one I've ranked 1st at the moment the basketball with the magic top hat etc).
If you could add some creativity into it, I think it'd be near perfect.