Thank you for your responses! Good variety!
I am not really a fan of number one and I think that has to do with the "BSH" looking crowded in the star. I think they could work in the star, but for some reason it does not like that.
#2 does not have enough feel of character with just the black.
I really like the feel of number 3 with the color, tilted star and the text variation, for me, not sure why but it helps convey the sports part pretty effectively.
#4/5 I like the boldness and feel like the bronze conveys a more bold image there than the blue and as a result prefer the bronze.
I really liek the idea of conveying a bold/strong brand and feel like for the most part you did well on that.
I would like to see variations of the themes if at all possible but so far so good.