I really like the design and colors of #21. Is there any way to incorporate a "b" into the design logo? If you could manage to use that in the shape of the pacifier in an abstract way, I think it would be a strong competitor. Thank you for your hard work, it looks great!
i just noticed the pacifier on the end of the "Y" on entry #22. I really like that idea. I would love to see another variation of that logo with the tip of the "Y" even more prominent and making it look like even more of a pacifier. Thanks so much for this. I really like your work and hope to see more.
I really like your designs. Unfortunately, I don't know what suggestions to give to make them better and currently, they aren't my number 1 choice. I wish I had more constructive feedback but I don't know how to change them to make them better. If you have any ideas for variations I would love to see them but as it stands, I would be unable to choose your design as the winner. Which is bad because I really really do like the design it just needs ... something.
I do like them very much! However, I seem to be preferring the logos that somehow use the Pacifier as the "B" in "Binky". That is they don't have a regular letter "B" and therefore say "inky" but then the "B" is added by the image. I don't know if you can make your design do this somehow but I would be very interested in your logo if you could!
It's not allowed B replaced with "pacifier "B" ....IF that ideas came from another designer. BUT, if that idea is your, I would love to do that.!! At your rank 1 and 2 was did same execution (replaced B with pacifier and INKY letter then. In this case, I just try to respect the other designer's ideas :) Except, you posted in public comment to do that idea, and everybody can use that.
It was my idea and I can prove it from the comments I posted to the other designers. Thanks for being considerate of them. Please do go ahead and do that if you can figure out a way to make it look good. Thanks! I'm excited to see what you create.
Wow, you're incredibly fast and these are both great! Definitely a step in the right direction. But I think there's still something a little off for me and I can't really tell what it is.
I think... either the "B" looks a little 'squished' or... maybe if the top of the "B" was formed to be the entire sucker part of the pacifier. I mean, if it completely replaced the question mark looking part of the top. Obviously it would have to be rounded out a bit. I'm not artist and I'm really bad at giving feedback... if you have any of your own ideas please do what you think will look best. :)
I think you're really really close to being in my top 3 and I'm really enjoying your work. Thanks so much!!!
Now I think we can make it less squished by using the bottom swirl part of the B as the rim of the piece that separates the mouth part from the handle. That'll make it less busy too... which I think will help. You're really good at translating my thoughts into the design. I wish all the designers were as easy to communicate with and I hope that we get to work together in the future as well!
Nice! I think I really like #79 the most so far. #80 is too bold on the handle. In fact, I think I would like #79 more if the handle part was even smaller or less dark. The "B" should be the focal point.... which it is now, I'm just not sure if it's enough.
I think the only thing keeping this from being my favorite now is that the colors look a bit retro/faded. If we could try a color variation you might help tip the scale. My fiance likes yours the most and and she likes my favorite second. I think the colors are what would make me choose yours overall.
Hello beloempoenjanama, are you going to be able to make the changes I requested. I really like your logo but I wouldn't be able to choose it as it currently is.
Okay, I definitely think this is better. It looks less retro. Hmm... can we maybe try a different font for the 'inky'. One that's kinda playful and maybe with the letters slightly wobbly (I don't know what it's called).
I think the colors are still off for my tastes. I like your pacifier part just as much as the one I currently have ranked as first. Actually, I like everything about your logo except for the colors and maybe the styling of the letters. It just seems "off" to me but I don't know how to tell you to fix it.
Maybe the stroke width/color on the letters needs changing as well as the letter colors themselves.
I'm sorry, I wish I could be more productive with my feedback.
Also, absolute is still working on the logo so I hope you didn't take my last comments as a definitive statement of you winning. I didn't intend to imply that if I did. I am just really excited about your latest work and would be proud to show it as my logo even if it isn't the chosen winner. I almost wish I could buy a logo from each of you as I really can't decide which is better. :/
Anyway, you latest iteration is excellent and I'm very happy with your work. Thanks!!!
I'm so sorry to keep bouncing back and forth. Both of you are so talented. Although, at this point I'm learning towards absolute's design. I'm not completely sure why... there's just something about it that I like.
Do you have any other ideas for how we might improve your design? I really want the best logo possible and I would be happy with either of the top two entries. I don't want to keep wasting your time if you're out of ideas though. I'm just really not sure what to say or do to make your design better. It's almost perfect. :)
Okay, these colors helped me realize that it's definitely the stroke that I have a problem with... but I still don't know how to fix them. You're obviously very talented but I don't know what else to do/say to make the logo better... and I feel like I'm wasting a lot of your time.
Yeah, these are in the right direction. I definitely like these more. I still don't think it's quite enough to take first place though. Honestly, the two designs are both so amazing at this point. It's really hard to choose which one is better. Half choose yours and half choose the one from absolute. Again, I don't want to lead you on or waste your time but if you can think of any other changes that might swing the vote, please feel free to make them.