Try some variations that are more horizontal, to work in a horizontal website header space. Nice simple icons. Can try something mountain inspired also?
22 is nicely bold, but the BIG is too big...can you try decreasing the size of the BIG, and increasing the size of the weathergear part of it? You can drop the tagline from some options, as it is long and wordy, and we may not lock it up with the logo.
Can you develop #9 further? We this because it is abstract, communicates weather, but isn't limited to boating or mountain weather like some of the others. Can you develop more versions of the cyclone icon, perhaps with more detail where it overlaps?
#72 - #76 update work. I glad you already like the cyclone idea. I like it because it is one of most known extreme weather. It may be work well to represent your product characteristics. Next, I'll try to focus on developing this idea better and better. Thanks!