We really like #123, because it has the arrow, and also because it incorporates upward motion the shape of a star-like badge. but we don't feel like it's really competing with our top 3, and we're not sure what advice to give to make it better.
We don't want it to look too much like a star, but we feel like it has the potential to be really distinctive.
Can you try some more things with the blue arrow, and also put the logo on an app tile so that we can compare it with the others.