Entry #1. A little too 3-d, shiny for us and too hypey. This should be a flat design. And I'd like to see the bars look more like a profit graph, perhaps with pale horizontal lines behind them for the graph. The arrow then would move up as the graph rose... something truly businesslike.
Entry #1. Lastly, the handwritten signature should be much smaller - it should not be a focus point but rather a tinioer part of the design that does not really catch the eye
#70,71,73: I like these a lot, but feel that my tagline is too small, it could run across the entire bottom and be more readable instead of being squished to the right. I would also prefer not to italicize the tagline because that makes it hard to read as well. The top-line "anne holland" needs to be the more formal 'An Anne Holland Publication" as seen on my WhichTestWon.com logo and actually is far less important than the other elements of the logo... it can move if you want or be smaller