Thank you for your post. You are on the right track. Your concepts are a bit too cartoonish, however, and need a bit more sophistication. The award can't look like stock art with our logo, it must look custom. The Web 100 logo on the following page was what I based my own version on (the award I uploaded): http://www.americaneagle.com/awards. I like how clean and well designed it is. I don't necessarily want a ribbon. Thank you!