Promo.comLogo Design Contest

Thank you to all who are participating here. This is our first project with logotournament, so we spent the first day or two learning protocol. Here's some additional feedback that might help:

I like the reability of the logo in #2. The cart wheels as "o"s in #6 and #5 is a great ideal, very well executed. I like the tag ideas in #3 and #4. Having the dot in dot com as the hole in the price tag (#3) is a really nice touch.

Would love to see some designs that get beyond shopping carts, bags and tags as some associate carts with groceries, and bags and tags with retail.

Perhaps a few more concepts that incorporate people? This tournament is far from over...

Like the look of happy people in #13. Would still like to see some designs that get beyond the shopping carts, bags and tags.

Can anyone here please offer us some original design concepts that go beyond the obvious shopping carts, tags and bags?

Some businesses are product oriented and some are customer/client oriented. We want to be seen as customer oriented, which is why we would prefer to see more happy people and fewer shopping carts, bags and tags. While we want to move away from the cart/bag approach, we like the fully integrated concept of #28 and the new movement added a nice touch. We like the happy people in #29 and LOVE the simplicity, readability and smiley face incorporated into #31. Readability of .com remains important in all submitted designs. Hope this helps.

At this point, our primary challenge is selecting the overall design concept that best represents our brand. Once that's decided, we can start fine tuning variations. So right now, we are primarily ranking by overall design style, with variations on a theme assigned lower rankings. For this reason, one version of a design style might be ranked very high, while very similar versions of the same style might be ranked quite a bit lower. Doesn't mean we don't like them. Just trying to keep our top concept picks organized.

We like the clean design and readabilty of #33. It's reminicent of Nike and Amazon without being either one. We like the happy people depicted in #35. Drawbacks to each of these is that they don't actually convey what we do.

We like the movement and the integration of the logo with the design element of the shopping cart in #28. This conveys the idea of shopping, but is more product centered than client centered.

Our logo should make people feel good when they see it. We want them to feel comfortable with us. Our value proposition is that we're better than discounts, better than coupons, better than bargains and better than deal sites. So before they buy anything, they should come to promo.com.

Not sure how much of that can be conveyed with a logo. But like many (annoying) design clients, we're hoping we'll know it when we see it.

Thank you to all for participating. Please keep the new concepts flowing.

LAST MINUTE IDEAS:

Perhaps a design indicating that you can save money by clicking on promo.com?
Or something indicating that LOTS of people LOVE going to promo.com?
Or something indicating that people are tossing their coupons in favor of promo.com?
Or something indicating that promos are BETTER than plain old coupons or discounts?

At this point, we are really only looking for cool, new concepts. No more variations on things already submitted, unless they are substantially and dramatically DIFFERENT and BETTER.

Thank you!

We're down to the last 8 hours in the contest and have seen some great designs.

At this point, we are only looking for cool, new concepts. No more variations on things already submitted, unless they are substantially and dramatically DIFFERENT and BETTER.

To all designers who have submitted designs, thank you for working on this project!

We are actively receiving feedback and checking the designs, only 2 hours remaining!

About 15 minutes left in the contest, if you have any last minute entries... now is the time to submit them!

ALL DESIGNERS PLEASE NOTE: Once the contest has ended, we will take a few days to compile our feedback, complete the final rankings and select the first place logo. We should have a decision by mid next week.

Thank you for all of the wonderful designs!

Thank you to all the designers who submitted entries for our contest! We took the the ranking process very seriously and ranked the top 22 designs in order from the feedback we received.

Continued success to all!