Thanks for your submission! This is very creative and outside "our" box. It's always great to get other suggestions. We like the colors and fonts used just not sure about the shape of the icon. The black portion seems to jump out as us too much. Would rather see that toned down a bit and another design or shape used.
Thank you for the feedback and ranking..I've taken in your suggestions and revised the round shield..this is clean not not overly glossy shining..over doing the shiny-gloss effect will actually ruin a good design The key is finding the balance...plus you need to see how design look in black and white if a design cannot hold up as pure black and white it's not a good a good composition.
#124 and #125 -- good point about the black and white. I can imagine there will be times when the color will not be used - i.e., black and white copies, etc. We're still considering your concept. Thanks!