#1 - I like the overall concept. I do like the bright colors, but it feels a little to cartoon-like for me. Also, I think the sunburst in the background feels too much like Groupon. I love how you captured the tower from the courthouse in Noblesville.
I like the feel of #9 better than #1. It feels less glossy and more real. But I think the spacing of #1 is better.
There is too much negative space in #9. The trees and sky take up most of the logo. I feel like the logo should be focused on the buildings and/or town hall.
#10 - I think the logo itself for this is great. But after examining it, I think the title and tagline get lost. We need to find a way to make them much more noticeable.