The word "Alumni" needs to have the same prominence as "Emerald Bay". The full name is "Emerald Bay Alumni" and is referred to with the full name, or just "EBA" for short. (If someone says "EB" they mean the camp, not the alumni group... so anytime we have initials, it's EBA).
I'll get you more specific feedback on the designs later today.
The pirate ha in #35, #40, #41 t is a little too cheesy. The swords in #34 are interesting, though! Would be better if the alumni was a little more prominent there... is there a way to get the swords and text to be more "connected" somehow? (Not necessarily physically--maybe just in style). Right now the font isn't all that interesting, and the swords and name just seem independent.