On #12, I like the word mark, but now that it's more rounded, it conflicts with the square logo. Maybe try rounding the corners of the logo to make it consistent with the words?
I don't really have a favorite color yet. I'm more interested about the design for now. Once I choose that, I'll ask for a few different color ideas to see which I like the most.
Also, while it looks great, I don't think I want the reflection on the logo for now.
I really like how #15 give the "C" for critic and the "o" for opia, but I would like to see if we could maybe try put a movie reel as the "o" or something like that. I just want to have some tie into movies if possible.
I liked #36 a lot, but I got a lot of responses that it looks too much like a crescent - ala the Algerian flag. I still think it looks cool, but I think it doesn't say what we do.
#63 is an interesting concept. It doesn't quite give me enough information on what the company does however. It suggests movies, but not critics/ratings or community.
By the way, I've decided upon gold/yellow as the main logo color.