Bullrunning.comLogo Design Contest

feedback?

Hi pecomun, you're more likely to get additional entries if you update the ranking and provide feedback to the designers.

Some of the proposals are too classic and the icon is proportionally too big regarding the brand name.
Modern typography (easy to read) is preferred.
Flags or any other Spanish symbol are not appropriate for the contest.
Be careful with the type of bull used for the symbol. Some of them look too Americans (close to buffalos) and far away from fighting bulls

Sorry but you lost me with the last feedback... In the brief it is stated that the bullrun is 'traditional'. One would then lean to create 'classical' proposals. (I don't think Steve Jobs said: "An apple? Naahh... I don't want that. I want some futuristic WEB 2.0..." ;-)

I'm not making fun of you I just say that it's hard to meet the content of the brief without feedback that in more detail specifies what you are looking for: Traditional, Timeless, New Age, Hip, Futuristic....

According to the brief it can be a Pictoral Mark, and that means it can be presented as a symbol without text. So how can the icon be 'proportionally too big'? Just trying to understand your preference.

Happy for feedback. :-)

Regards

It would also be nice if you could rank (1,2,3...) the top contenders that you like the most. It is both a useful tool for the designer, as well as serving as a grading of how well our work is appreciated, meaning it helps other contest holder for future contests.

Thanks!

This post was used on a different competition to highlight some rules of the LT (previously posted by Dazzle - Moderator for LT)

" March 22nd, 2009, 11:48am
How are you doing ? hope you are doing great. As this contest is about to come to an end, and you will be chosing the best new logo for your company, i just wanted to have your attention to some important point that you might be aware of or might not. I hope i am not miss understood by pointing out this to you and that you understand.

When the contest ends and you have made your mind and desicion about the winner logo, the winner gets the 1st place, but the 2nd and 3rd place and going on forward, 4th, 5th, 6th , etc , each one or slot should be filled with a seperate designer and different concept you found second best, third best to follow etc.

This helps towards us designers ranking and also it is a way from you to show your appreciation to the hard effort and trails put from the beginning by one designer or appreciating a nice design concept put earlier by a designer that led to developing on right direction for others and you getting the best you could at the end.

It feels frustrating for other designers and pointless of giving all the top rankings for same winner designer, while those were just a small variations of the winning design and therefore the other places 2nd, 3rd, 4th, etc are not filled with different designs from a different designer.

So i hope you understood my point i was just trying to point out to you here and all the best of luck in chosing your winner logo, there are really good ones out there.

Best Regards,

Kareem"